Our favorite under-eye concealers include formulas from Kosas and Trinny London. (Images via Sephora and Trinny London )
As a longtime beauty editor, I get more questions about how to find the best under-eye concealers than any other question I've ever been asked. Truth is, most of us — no matter what our age — remain confused about which under-eye concealer we should buy and it's easy to see why: there are hundreds on the market, in an array of delivery systems, textures, colors, coverage levels and even finishes. So many in fact that it can be tough, if not downright intimidating, to find the right option for your skin, your makeup style — and your budget.
When used correctly, a good concealer can disguise myriad facial blemishes, dark spots and circles; it can make our faces appear brighter and even more awake, particularly as we age. When done wrong, however, a bad under-eye concealer can make you look like Bette Davis in Whatever Happened to Baby Jane?
To help mitigate the confusion, over the past year, I tried more than 30 different concealer brands. I tested them all on my 52-year-old under-eye area and rated them according to coverage, finish (did they settle into fine lines? did they make the area look dry?) and value. Finally, I asked professional makeup artists for tips on how to actually apply this mythical makeup workhorse, how to choose one's correct shade, plus the concealer mistakes we're all making and how to stop — starting today.
The best under-eye concealers of 2025
Update, June 10, 2025: We checked all product prices and availability. Our number one pick for best under-eye concealer remains unchanged.
For the uninitiated, here are a few concealer basics: There are essentially five main categories of concealer: gel, liquid, stick, cream and cream to powder. Of these, the best for the under-eye area tend to be gel, liquid, stick and, to a lesser extent, cream.
Each category has its dark-circle/under-eye coverage advantages and, depending on your age and skin type, major disadvantages. Makeup artists I spoke with differed wildly on the "best" formula, but most all agreed that the area needs to be hydrated for any of these products to work effectively. This is especially true if you're trying to find the best under-eye concealer for mature skin.
Given this, and the fact that I'm lazy, there was one clear everyday concealer winner for me and my skin type (combination) and makeup preference (not much):
Formulation: Gel | Finish: Lightly dewy | Number of shades: 12 | Coverage: Light
I love everything about this award-winning serum/gel concealer from Trinny London which, according to the brand, sells one tube every 15 seconds. I love that it's a highly hydrating skin-care/makeup hybrid, which means I don't need an eye cream when I use it. I like how the applicator is slightly tilted and fits into tighter crevices, like the corner of under-eye hollows. I especially enjoy the light coverage for a more natural look (though you can certainly build it up for more medium coverage). Maybe best of all, the clever “color match” quiz helps you find which of the 12 available shades is the best for you with eerie accuracy.
I did not love how long it took to arrive (10 days) and that the shipping was $13, but honestly, if you have older skin and want a light coverage, natural "no makeup" look (my fave), this is for you.
Formulation: Gel | Finish: Satiny | Number of shades: 15 | Coverage: Medium
This gel formula serum + concealer goes on sheer and natural looking and the finish is satiny-smooth. It's buildable — layer more on days when you need heavier coverage. It's compact, comes in a dozen different shades and is — perhaps best of all — affordable. (Full disclosure: the formula did settle into at least one or two of my fine lines, but I could easily blur it back out with a sponge or a brush.
Formulation: Gel | Finish: Satiny | Number of shades: 4 | Coverage: Lightweight
This lightweight gel concealer is not only Vanessa Williams's favorite, it's also the first one mentioned by makeup artist Rebecca Restrepo, who named it the best concealer on the market: "It’s a crease-free and buildable concealer in a gel form that applies smoothly over fine lines and wrinkles," she says. "It’s never cakey. The formula has skin-care ingredients like alpha lipoic acid, vitamin C, hyaluronic acid and caffeine to add moisture and reduce the appearance of dark circles and puffy skin."
When I tried it, I found the formulation to glide on just as Restrepo said, giving ample coverage and leaving a silky finish I liked. My only issue with this product is, while the shade I picked ("Luminous") worked for my skin and the brand says they use an exclusive "smart tint technology" that matches your skin tone by using the skin’s natural pH, there are still only four options to choose from, which — perhaps even with this technology — may be limiting for many skin tones.
Formulation: Stick | Finish: Matte | Number of shades: 13 | Coverage: Full
I tried Jillian Dempsey's concealer stick after applying an ample layer of Tatcha's Eye Brightener Serum. The combination made my dark circles all but disappear. The finish of the JD concealer is smooth and matte which balanced the more greasy serum. What I especially liked about this product was how it stayed on most of the day and, when I wanted a little extra coverage later, was super easy to apply on the go. One caveat: On another day, when my under-eye area was dryer/without serum, the stick was a bit crumbly and harder to apply and blend.
Formulation: Stick | Finish: Matte | Number of shades: 25 | Coverage: Medium
This cleverly designed face pencil is part of makeup artist extraordinaire Bobbi Brown's line Jones Road. It's a surprisingly excellent replacement for traditional liquid concealers — ideal for zeroing in on any place you want coverage (under eyes, redness around the nose) and blends beautifully without any kind of caking or settling into fine lines. I love using it to color in my under-eye area almost in the same way you would a lip liner for lips. The pencil blends easily and the effect is super natural — this is an innovative product and a stellar concealer for all areas of the face. The only downside I found through testing is it melts off fairly quickly on combination skin, requiring that you reapply.
Formulation: Stick | Finish: Dewy | Number of shades: 30 | Coverage: Light
Merit's Minimalist Perfecting Complexion Foundation and Concealer Stick provided all the under-eye/blemish/age-spot camouflaging I was looking for while also gliding on super-smooth and adding moisture back into my skin. The coverage is light for sure, but if that's what you're looking for, this easy, creamy jumbo stick can be applied all over, blends well and feels natural. I like the coverage, but if you're looking for medium to full coverage, this isn't your pick.
Formulation: Liquid | Finish: Matte | Number of shades: 26 | Coverage: Full
This e.l.f version is makeup artist Restrepo's second favorite concealer and it's easy to see why: It's weirdly non-creasy while also being full coverage and it has long-wearing power — mine stayed put for the whole workday. It contains hyaluronic acid and caffeine to nourish the under-eye area and reduce the appearance of dark circles while you wear it. Last, you can't beat the price: $7.
Not to be the concealer Eeyore, but... even with all these wonderful qualities, this formula was a bit thick for my taste, more paste than liquid. Still, with 26 shades to choose from and 33,000 5-star reviews, it's absolutely worth a try.
Formulation: Liquid | Finish: Dewy | Number of shades: 28 | Coverage: Full
I first heard about Kosas's cult-favorite concealer from TikTok makeup queen Hailey Bieber: “I just love that it’s creamy and hydrating and leaves this dewy finish on the skin,” she said in this Vogue “Beauty Secrets” video from last year. When I tried it I found it to be those things, yes (especially when applied over eye cream) but also just a wee bit gloopy for my (admittedly heavy-makeup adverse) preferences. Still, this is a quality, full-coverage concealer; beloved by makeup artists, TikTok and celebrities alike. If you're looking for a classic liquid concealer in a high-quality formulation (including skin-health-boosting ingredients hyaluronic acid and caffeine) and with 28 (!) shade options, this is a good bet.
Formulation: Liquid | Finish: Matte | Number of shades: 28 | Coverage: Medium
OK, so at first you're going to think the sponge applicator on this concealer is a little weird. It is. But it's also kind of perfect for swooshing on the under-eye area, though, strangely not great for blending (it was fine, I used my fingers). The product itself is moisturizing and non-creasy, which is honestly a feat at this price point. It offers smooth, medium coverage that's ideal for dark circles. Keep in mind the finish is matte, which I REPEAT Is not always flattering for mature skin, so you may want to generously hydrate the area before you apply.
Formulation: Liquid-gel | Finish: Dewy | Number of shades: 12 | Coverage: Light
Though not a skin-care/makeup hybrid per se, Ami Colé's concealer contains loads of skin-nourishing ingredients like baobab seed, hibiscus flower and vitamin E extracts which soothe delicate undereye skin and help it retain moisture. It's a lighter coverage liquid concealer (maybe more like a gel?) that leaves behind a dewy finish — which I happen to like, though other users I spoke with felt they needed powder after applying to thwart the shine.
Formulation: Cream | Finish: Matte | Number of shades: 30 | Coverage: Full
I don't think I'm legally allowed to write a best concealer list without including Nars, and this magical full-coverage potion does not disappoint. It's for those days when you want to look flawlessly DONE, it covers every imperfection in your skin and due to its matte "optical diffusion powder" formula which "transforms the look of skin by blurring imperfections with light-diffusing spheres," it's ideal for long-wear on even the oiliest skin. I found the thick texture to be a bit tricky to sort out at first, but when applied with a brush and just a tiny bit of eye cream, it went on smooth. This is for true makeup people who like lots of coverage — it's also good for hiding dark spots, acne scars and other discoloration on the skin.
"I recommend a concealer that will not only even out skin tone and blur imperfections but also help improve the skin," says celebrity makeup artist Rebecca Restrepo (her clients include Debra Messing, Lucy Liu and Jessica Williams). In our interview, Restrepo steered me toward the new (to me) category of gel concealers: "I like gel formulas because they tend to glide over the skin easily without pulling skin that may not be as taut. They also tend to not settle into fine lines, which is a concern as we age."
After gel, the best category of under-eye concealer (and, honestly, concealer period) I tested on my own skin is the stick. Concealer sticks are versatile, super easy to apply (no mess!) and blend. Plus, unlike matte cream versions, they won't highlight your under eye wrinkles or soak into fine lines. Stick concealers also tend to give fuller coverage if that’s what you’re looking for. Just note that a stick formula might be a little too heavy for those with oily skin.
Makeup artist Jillian Dempsey also favors the stick concealer, explaining that the key to successful application is using it in tandem with a moisturizer. Dempsey, whose A-list clients include Jennifer Lawrence and Kate Winslet (along with her husband, McDreamy/Patrick Dempsey), uses her own line to achieve the desired result. "Everyone's preference is different but I like to add a thin layer of Mixturizer under my eyes and allow it to soak in a couple of minutes. Then I warm up my Spot Stick Concealer, which has a matte finish, and I tap and blend it out. I use [the shade] #05 and sometimes mix it with #03 for the best results. I’ll add more as needed but I like to only cover my dark circles under my eyes and on the inner corner area of my eyes."
Liquid concealers are the most common of all concealer types — if you've used this makeup staple before, this is most likely the version you've tried. They go on wet (obviously), but once dried, range in texture from dewy to matte. They work especially well when you're in your 20s, 30s and even 40s to disguise blemishes and dark spots but I found them less impressive in my 50s, as many emphasized wrinkles and crepey-ness and it was harder to find a color match.
If you're using this type of concealer for the under-eye area, it's important to note that while the product itself may be creamy, the final effect can look dry, so, if you're older — as with concealer sticks — it's crucial to moisturize the area first.
"To find your best shade, step out into the daylight with a mirror," advises Jillian Dempsey. "This will tell you everything you need to know." In terms of undertones, Dempsey says choosing warm tones (peach hues for lighter skin and orange tones for darker skin) work best for the under-eye area as they cancel out the blue in dark circles. "Orange covers blue," she explains.
And, while most experts suggest using a tone one to two shades lighter than the rest of your face to brighten the under-eye area, Dempsey cautions: "The biggest mistake I see people make is using a concealer with too much white pigment that bounces the light. A makeup artist’s worst nightmare is the white bounce back!" Instead of cool whites, go for warm, neutral tones closer to your natural skin color. Everyone's skin is different but two tricks have worked for me: matching my concealer to the inside of my wrist and to the skin on my neck.
Here's Rebecca Restrepo's expert technique for applying under-eye concealer: "Lightly dab a few dots of the concealer under the eyes. Pat and smooth with your fingertips. The warmth from your fingers will help blend the concealer into your skin so it looks natural. I like using fingers to blend on mature skin versus a brush so that you don’t pull at the skin. I like to start at the inside of the eye first as that is where the dark circles start at the hollowing, then moving towards the outside of the eye. The outside of the eye doesn’t need as much concealing and needs to be sheer as possible so it’s a veil and no collection of product in the fine lines. This way there is exact placement of product and amount for what is needed."
Under-eye concealers are supposed to help brighten and lift; but when used incorrectly, they can actually highlight unwanted attention around the area and make your eyes look worse. Restrepo and Dempsey share their expert tips on common under-eye concealer mistakes and how to avoid them.
Mistake #1: Using too much. "You should always start with a small amount and add additional product if necessary," says Restrepo.
Mistake #2: Applying concealer in a room with low light — or too much light. Restrepo says natural light is best for applying concealer, so you know how your skin will look like in most situations throughout the day. "Applying in the wrong light tends to mean you apply too much, or too little product, and not in the right areas where you actually need coverage," she says.
Mistake #3: Applying to the wrong parts of the face. "Mature women should wear less concealer and only in the areas in need of coverage, or else you make the wrinkles look too obvious," says Dempsey. "I suggest sticking to covering just the dark circle areas and not the 'smile lines' for a more youthful look. Moisturize first too and let it soak in for a hydrated look and feel."
Jillian Dempsey, Hollywood makeup artist
Rebecca Restrepo, Hollywood makeup artist
We received complimentary samples of some products and purchased others ourselves, but we reviewed all products using the same objective criteria.
Drink 'em in: We've tested and reviewed formulas from CosRx, Charlotte Tilbury, Cetaphil, La Roche-Posay and more.
BeautyHappy birthday, Dolly! We're stocking up on goodies — up to 50% off — to mark 77 years of the Backwoods Barbie.
BeautyClinique, Sunday Riley, Murad and more: From anti-aging heroes to flawless foundations, there's nothing more thrilling than shopping for skin-care gems with free money.
BeautyWe've tested and reviewed hundreds of face creams, serums, peels, toners and masks — these are our favorites.
BeautyThe secret to youthful-looking hands starts here: from CeraVe to Gold Bond, Neutrogena and more
BeautyFrom $10 caffeine serum to a French pharmacy staple used by Parisians for decades, the best eye creams for dark circles will brighten even the darkest orbital day.
BeautyWe tested dozens of under-eye patches — find out why Shiseido's Benefiance Express tops our list.
BeautyThe Body Exfoliator by Nécessaire is the GOAT when it comes to body scrubs — find out why we ranked it the best of the best.
BeautySpoil them with the Revlon One Step Dryer, Laneige Lip Sleeping Mask and so much more.
BeautyWe tested dozens of moisturizers, but there's a reason our top pick hasn't changed.
BeautyDr. Dennis Gross, Drunk Elephant, SkinMedica and Cerave will exfoliate your face and give you angel-soft skin.
BeautyNew to K-beauty? These picks from Peach & Lily, CosRx and Mediheal will work near-miracles for your skin.
BeautyWant to get serious about signs of aging? Don't overlook these potent helpers from Saint Jane, Vichy, Glow Recipe and more.
BeautyAfter testing several moisturizers for mature skin, we think this one from Dr Dennis Gross is the best — here's why.
BeautyAdd to cart, immediately: Cerave, PCA Skin, Bioré, Glow Recipe and more oily skin cleansers to kick sebum and dirt to the curb.
BeautyIn dire need of a hydrating face oil without all the scary stuff? Add The Outset Boosting Oil to your skin care routine and thank us later.
BeautyDark circles, begone! These best-in-class gels, creams and sticks will make you look more rested than you are.
Beauty'Saved my hair': Shoppers say this bestselling shampoo set is an anti-thinning powerhouse
BeautyFrom towels and tablets to leggings and lipstick, these tried-and-true buys won't disappoint.
Beauty