ElytStyle
ElytStyleWhy you can trust us
We independently evaluate the products we review. When you buy via links on our site, we may receive compensation.

Study says phones are just as good as wearables at tracking fitness

Jon Fingas
Jon Fingas

Think you have to wear a dedicated fitness tracker to get accurate data? Don't worry -- you may have a good excuse to skip the wristband. The University of Pennsylvania has published a study showing that smartphone apps' step counts are reasonably on the mark, at less than a 7 percent variance between their data and what observers saw first-hand. With wearables, it's all over the map. Some are very accurate, like Fitbit's One and Zip; others don't give you much of an advantage over a phone, and Nike's Fuelband was sometimes off by a wide margin.

This isn't to say that you should ditch wearables for good. The test only focused on six trackers, and didn't include either the latest devices (including smartwatches) or a wide range of activities. There are also certain situations where a phone simply isn't practical. You may not want to go on a run with your Galaxy or iPhone, for one thing. All the same, there's enough evidence here to suggest that your handset is good enough when you're only concerned about the distance you've walked in a given day.

Recommended articles

The best exercise mat for 2025, tested and approved by personal trainers

The best exercise mat for 2025, tested and approved by personal trainers

Fitness
The 8 best shaker bottles for post-workout nutrition in 2025

The 8 best shaker bottles for post-workout nutrition in 2025

Fitness
The 8 best electric bicycles of 2025, tested and editor-approved

The 8 best electric bicycles of 2025, tested and editor-approved

Fitness
Most iPhone exercise apps don't give you the best workout

Most iPhone exercise apps don't give you the best workout

Fitness
Best Buy will dedicate store space to 'smart' gym equipment

Best Buy will dedicate store space to 'smart' gym equipment

It'll include connected bikes, rowers and treadmills.

Fitness
This $21 waist trimmer will make you sweat—a lot: 'Best thing I've ever bought'

This $21 waist trimmer will make you sweat—a lot: 'Best thing I've ever bought'

Fitness
This face mask sells every 30 seconds — plus more bestsellers we shared on the Today Show

This face mask sells every 30 seconds — plus more bestsellers we shared on the Today Show

Fitness
Last chance: Amazon's 10 best Labor Day sales — from AirPods to Skechers

Last chance: Amazon's 10 best Labor Day sales — from AirPods to Skechers

Fitness
Here’s the scoop: Amazon's best-selling protein powders and energy supplements are up to 50 percent off today

Here’s the scoop: Amazon's best-selling protein powders and energy supplements are up to 50 percent off today

Fitness
QVC has quietly rolled out some of the best holiday weekend deals around — score up to 70 percent!

QVC has quietly rolled out some of the best holiday weekend deals around — score up to 70 percent!

Fitness
I’m a mom — and these are the 10 best things I’ve ever bought at Amazon

I’m a mom — and these are the 10 best things I’ve ever bought at Amazon

Fitness
Work it: Amazon's No. 1 bestselling waist trimmer is just $14 for Prime Day!

Work it: Amazon's No. 1 bestselling waist trimmer is just $14 for Prime Day!

Fitness
This top-rated waist trimmer is $19 at Amazon for Black Friday: 'Best thing I've ever bought'

This top-rated waist trimmer is $19 at Amazon for Black Friday: 'Best thing I've ever bought'

Fitness
Amazon just launched an epic sale on fitness gear, from dumbbells to treadmills: These are the best deals

Amazon just launched an epic sale on fitness gear, from dumbbells to treadmills: These are the best deals

Fitness
Turn your bike into an indoor trainer with Amazon's No. 1 bestselling stand — now $35

Turn your bike into an indoor trainer with Amazon's No. 1 bestselling stand — now $35

Fitness
Amazon's Sunday Presidents' Day deals are epic — here are the 70+ absolute best sales

Amazon's Sunday Presidents' Day deals are epic — here are the 70+ absolute best sales

Fitness
Here are today's 5 best Amazon deals — starting at just $13

Here are today's 5 best Amazon deals — starting at just $13

Fitness
46 best fitness gifts for the active person in your life

46 best fitness gifts for the active person in your life

Fitness
Best walking workout: Here's how to start walking for exercise

Best walking workout: Here's how to start walking for exercise

Fitness
This bestselling smart scale tracks way more than weight, and it's down to $22

This bestselling smart scale tracks way more than weight, and it's down to $22

Fitness
Article does not exist